1990 Score John Olerud #589 Baseball Card Values

Manufacturer: Score
Set: 1990 Score Baseball ➡️
Player Name: John Olerud
Position/Team: Outfield for Blue Jays
Card #: 589
Card Size: 2-1/2” x 3-1/2”

Card Value Snapshot: Raw/Ungraded: $1 | Grade 10: $32
⬇️ See More Pricing Data Below

John Olerud is a former professional baseball player known for his sweet, left-handed swing, exceptional discipline at the plate, and a distinctive habit of wearing his batting helmet in the field. He had a 17-season career in Major League Baseball (MLB) as a first baseman, playing for five different teams.

His promising career was nearly derailed by a subarachnoid hemorrhage (a type of brain seizure) he suffered in 1989. After recovering from surgery, he chose to sign with the Toronto Blue Jays, who promised he would report directly to the majors without playing in the minors. The brain aneurysm is the reason he wore a batting helmet in the field throughout his career as a precautionary measure.

Olerud was a key member of the Blue Jays’ World Series championship teams in 1992 and 1993. His breakout season came in 1993, when he won the American League batting title with a .363 average and flirted with hitting .400 for much of the season.

Olerud continued to be a productive hitter for the New York Mets. He was part of what was famously dubbed “the best infield in baseball history” by Sports Illustrated, alongside Edgardo Alfonzo, Rey Ordóñez, and Robin Ventura.

Olerud returned to his home state of Washington and played a crucial role for the Mariners. He won three Gold Glove Awards for his stellar defense at first base during his time in Seattle.

After retiring from baseball in 2005, Olerud was inducted into the National College Baseball Hall of Fame in 2007. The College Baseball Foundation created the John Olerud Two-Way Player of the Year Award in his honor, given annually to the best dual hitter/pitcher at the collegiate level.

Shop current listings for this card on ebay!
Clicking a link to eBay may result in a referral commission being paid if a purchase is made.

Pricing Data For This Rookie Card

Tracking the current market value for the 1990 Score John Olerud Card #589. Below, find updated pricing data for ungraded (raw) copies, as well as verified PSA graded sales trends collected from secondary marketplaces.

Raw/Ungraded: $1
Grade 8: $10
Grade 9: $15
Grade 10: $32

Data Updated: September 2026

➡️ See All 1990 Score Rookie Card Prices

Pricing data includes raw card price & some graded card value estimates.
These values are collated from a variety of resources including recently sold listings, sales averages and a variety of other sports card pricing data sources. Please see full disclaimer on “Terms Page” for more information. (Rookiecardprices.com only shows values for regular base set cards. No prices are shown for errors, parallels, subsets, misprints or other cards unless noted.)

DISCLAIMER: This data is not intended as financial advice and should not be used as such. Please do your own research before making any investment or selling/buying decisions. The use of any trademarked name, logo, or brand imagery on this website is strictly for card identification, historical reference, and descriptive market analysis purposes only.

Did You Know? What cemented Olerud as a truly unique, beloved character in baseball folklore was his signature look on the field. Due to his collegiate brain surgery, Olerud was strongly advised by doctors to wear a protective plastic shell inside his cap. Finding it cumbersome, he elected to simply wear his standard batting helmet while playing first base defense throughout his entire 14-year major league career.

This created a highly distinct visual trademark that fans across the globe immediately recognized. It also led to a hilarious, widespread urban legend in the late 90s claiming that teammate Rickey Henderson saw Olerud in the dugout and said, “I used to play with a guy in Toronto who wore a helmet on defense too,” completely forgetting they were the exact same person.