Manufacturer: Score
Set: 1991 Score Baseball ➡️
Player Name: Mike Lieberthal
Position/Team: Catcher for Phillies
Card #: 683
Card Size: 2-1/2” x 3-1/2”
Card Value Snapshot: Raw/Ungraded: $1 | Grade 10: $35
⬇️ See More Pricing Data Below
Drafted 3rd overall by the Philadelphia Phillies in the 1st round of the 1990 MLB Draft out of Westlake High School (CA), Michael Scott “Mike” Lieberthal was a staple behind the plate for the Phillies for more than a decade, recognized for his clean receiving, strong arm, and elite offensive production during his prime.
Lieberthal played 14 Major League seasons (1994–2007)—13 with Philadelphia followed by a final season with the Los Angeles Dodgers. Over 1,212 career games, he compiled 1,155 hits, 257 doubles, 150 home runs, and 610 RBIs with a .274 career batting average. He holds the Phillies franchise record for most career games caught (1,139) and home runs hit by a catcher (149).
Lieberthal emerged as one of the National League’s premier modern backstops at the turn of the century.
Historic 1999 Breakout Season: Turned in one of the single best seasons by a catcher in Philadelphia history, batting .300 with 31 home runs, 33 doubles, 96 RBIs, and a .551 slugging percentage. He became just the eighth catcher in MLB history to hit .300 with 30+ homers in a single season.
1999 Gold Glove Award: Led all National League catchers with a .997 fielding percentage—setting a franchise record at the position while committing just two errors all season to earn his first Gold Glove.
Back-to-Back All-Star (1999–2000): Selected to represent the National League in consecutive All-Star Games.
2002 Comeback Player of the Year: After losing most of 2001 to a severe knee injury (ACL/MCL tear), Lieberthal roared back in 2002 by batting .279 with 15 home runs and 52 RBIs, earning The Sporting News NL Comeback Player of the Year honors.
Shop current listings for this card on ebay!
Clicking a link to eBay may result in a referral commission being paid if a purchase is made.
Pricing Data For This Rookie Card
Tracking the current market value for the 1991 Score Mike Lieberthal Rookie Card #683. Below, find updated pricing data for ungraded (raw) copies, as well as verified PSA graded sales trends collected from secondary marketplaces.
-
Raw/Ungraded: $1
-
Grade 8:
-
Grade 9: $8
-
Grade 10: $35
Data Updated: November 2026
➡️ See All 1991 Score Rookie Card Prices
Pricing data includes raw card price & some graded card value estimates.
These values are collated from a variety of resources including recently sold listings, sales averages and a variety of other sports card pricing data sources. Please see full disclaimer on “Terms Page” for more information. (Rookiecardprices.com only shows values for regular base set cards. No prices are shown for errors, parallels, subsets, misprints or other cards unless noted.)
DISCLAIMER: This data is not intended as financial advice and should not be used as such. Please do your own research before making any investment or selling/buying decisions. The use of any trademarked name, logo, or brand imagery on this website is strictly for card identification, historical reference, and descriptive market analysis purposes only.
Did You Know? Caught Millwood’s No-Hitter: On April 27, 2003, Lieberthal was behind the plate to call and catch Kevin Millwood’s no-hitter against the San Francisco Giants at Veterans Stadium.
More Rookie Cards From 1991 Score





