1991 Score Baseball Card Price Guide

1991 Score baseball rookie cards
Manufacturer: Score
Set Size: 893 Cards
Card Size: 2-1/2” x 3-1/2”

Set Notes: The card fronts of 1991 Score baseball utilized full-color action photography with the player’s name set in bold lettering across the upper border. Most of the rookie card have white borders and show either “1st Round Draft Pick” or “Rookie Prospect”. The backs remained among the best in the industry at the time: full-color action/portrait photos, extensive career statistics, and detailed biographical notes printed on clean white stock.

Key Rookies From 1991 Score:   |  383 – Mike Mussina  |  389 – Todd Van Poppel  |  671 – Chipper Jones

Pricing chart includes raw card price & some graded card value estimates.
These values are collated from a variety of resources including recently sold listings, sales averages and a variety of other sports card pricing data sources. Please see full disclaimer on “Terms Page” for more information.
(Rookiecardprices.com only shows values for regular base set cards. No prices are shown for errors, parallels, subsets, misprints or other cards unless noted.)

DISCLAIMER: This data is not intended as financial advice and should not be used as such. Please do your own research before making any investment or selling/buying decisions. The use of any trademarked name, logo, or brand imagery on this website is strictly for card identification, historical reference, and descriptive market analysis purposes only.



(–) : No Pricing Data Available  |  ($) USD Price Value  |  (¢) USD Price Under $1

The Free 1991 Score Rookie Card Price Guide

Tracking the current market value for the 1991 Score Baseball Rookie Cards. Below, find updated pricing data for ungraded (raw) copies, as well as verified PSA graded sales trends collected from secondary marketplaces.

RookieCard #Raw8910
Tom Edens7825¢ - - -
Brian McRae33125¢ - - -
Pedro Munoz33225¢ - - -
Daryl Irvine33325¢ - - -
Jeff Schulz33625¢ - - -
Mike Bordick339$1 - $30 $40
Jim Vatcher34125¢ - - -
Pete Coachman34425¢ - - -
Tim McIntosh34725¢ - - -
Phil Plantier34850¢ - - -
Dave Walsh35125¢ - - -
Anthony Telford35425¢ - - -
Terry Wells35925¢ - - -
Paul Abbott363$1 - $7 $35
Rafael Novoa36625¢ - - -
Joe Grahe36725¢ - - -
Darren Reed36825¢ - - -
Mark Dewey37125¢ - - -
Mark Lee37225¢ - - -
Rosario Rodriguez37325¢ - - -
Mike Bell37575¢ - - -
Bill Haselman37725¢ - - -
Dave Pavlas37825¢ - - -
Jeromy Burnitz38025¢ - - -
Don Peters38125¢ - - -
Mike Mussina383$1 $8 $18 $40
Dan Smith38425¢ - - -
Lance Dickson38550¢ - - -
Carl Everett386$1 - $7 $12
Tom Nevers38725¢ - - -
Adam Hyzdu38825¢ - - -
Todd Van Poppel389$1 $8 $20 $85
Rondell White39075¢ - - -
Marc Newfield39175¢ - - -
John Barfield57350¢ - - -
Jeff Gray58625¢ - - -
Rich Rodriguez59325¢ - - -
Chipper Jones671$1 $12 $20 $50
Eric Christopherson67225¢ - - -
Robbie Beckett67325¢ - - -
Shane Andrews67425¢ - - -
Steve Karsay67525¢ - - -
Aaron Holbert67625¢ - - -
Donovan Osborne67725¢ - - -
Todd Ritchie67825¢ - - -
Ron Walden67925¢ - - -
Tim Costo68025¢ - - -
Dan Wilson68125¢ - - -
Kurt Miller68225¢ - - -
Mike Lieberthal683$1 $8 $35
Brian Barnes70825¢ - - -
Steve Decker71025¢ - - -
Paul Faries71125¢ - - -
Paul Marak71225¢ - - -
Wes Chamberlain71325¢ - - -
Kevin Belcher71425¢ - - -
Steve Adkins71625¢ - - -
Mark Leonard71925¢ - - -
Mike Gardiner72150¢ - - -
Jeff Conine72275¢ - - $8
Efrain Valdez72325¢ - - -
Paul McClellan72625¢ - - -
Mark Leiter727$1 - - -
Rich DeLucia72825¢ - - -
Hector Wagner73025¢ - - -
Turner Ward73225¢ - - -
Gerald Alexander73325¢ - - -
Scott Anderson73425¢ - - -
Mike York73825¢ - - -
Dave Burba74225¢ - - -
Ray Stephens74325¢ - - -
Troy Afenir74525¢ - - -
Orlando Merced74725¢ - - -
Omar Olivares74825¢ - - -
Matt Stark75125¢ - - -
Randy Hennis75225¢ - - -
Phil Clark75625¢ - - -
Ed Vosberg757$1 - - -
Mike Perez75825¢ - - -
Scott Lewis75925¢ - - -
Steve Chitren76025¢ - - -
Ray Young76125¢ - - -
Rodney McCray76325¢ - - -
Sean Berry76425¢ - - -
Mike Simms76625¢ - - -
Glenn Sutko76725¢ - - -
Randy Tomlin78225¢ - - -
Jim Neidlinger79425¢ - - -
Chris Nabholz80425¢ - - -
Data Updated: November 2026

Right Now on eBay Shop 1991 Score Baseball Cards
Clicking a link to eBay may result in a referral commission being paid if a purchase is made.
Loading...

Overview of 1991 Score Baseball Cards

The 1991 Score baseball release represents the absolute peak of Junk Wax Era volume paired with early-90s graphic design experimentation. Following up on its massive 1990 set, Major League Marketing expanded Score into a massive two-series checklist featuring distinct, color-coded border themes and landmark subset concepts.

Set Structure & Design: Score split its main set across two series, totaling a massive 893-card base checklist.

  • Series 1 (#1–441): Featured vibrant, solid-colored outer borders (blue, green, purple, red, orange) framing the inner photo.

  • Series 2 (#442–882): Switched to a uniform, clean white border layout.

  • Factory Set Exclusives (#883–893): Eleven additional cards were added exclusively to 1991 Score factory sets, including special ‘First Round Draft Pick’ cards.

The card fronts utilized full-color action photography with the player’s name set in bold, white block lettering across the upper border. The backs remained among the best in the industry at the time: full-color action/portrait photos, extensive career statistics, and detailed biographical notes printed on clean white stock.

Notable Rookies / First Prospect Cards: Mike Mussina (#383) and Chipper Jones (#671 – Draft Pick/Rookie Prospect).

Rare Chases & Factory Promotions: 1991 Score was also famous for a few unique distribution quirks and chase cards.

  • Mickey Mantle Autographed Cards: Score placed original autographs of Mickey Mantle directly into random Series 2 packs, with cards certified and hand-numbered to 2,500.

  • 100th Anniversary Stamped Promos: Special promo versions were distributed at the National Sports Collectors Convention featuring a gold foil 100th Anniversary stamp.

Subsets / Inserts:

  • 100th Anniversary / Cooperstown: Series 1 (#386–429 ) : Celebrated classic Hall of Fame inductees and baseball history.

  • Dream Team: Series 2 (#848–873) : Famous, high-contrast black and white photo cards showcasing elite superstars (e.g., Will Clark, Ken Griffey Jr., Ryne Sandberg).

  • The Franchise: Series 2 (#874–882) : A sleek, black-bordered insert block celebrating defining team leaders like Frank Thomas and Wade Boggs.

  • K-Man / Master Blaster: Themed subsets highlighting single-season statistical monsters in home runs and strikeouts.

  • Cooperstown Collection Inserts: A 5-card insert set highlighting classic legends like Mickey Mantle, Carl Yastrzemski, and Stan Musial.

Collector’s Takeaway: 1991 Score captures the colorful, high-energy aesthetic of early 1990s collecting. While standard base cards are abundant, chasing pristine high-grade copies of the Dream Team and The Franchise subsets—or searching for the rare pack-inserted Mickey Mantle autographs—remains a fun nostalgia trip for ’90s enthusiasts.


download a pdf checklist for this setDownload the 1991 Score Rookie Card Checklist PDF


1991 Score Baseball Set FAQ

Q: How can I instantly recognize the card layout for 1991 Score?

A: Score completely overhauled their frame for 1991 by adopting vibrant, asymmetric colored border bars along the top and right sides. The borders rotate in bright primary and neon colors depending on the team color scheme. The player’s photo is angled, and the bottom left corner features a distinctive, overlapping circle housing the team logo, right alongside clean block lettering for the player’s name and position.

Q: Are there any notable error cards or printing variations to hunt for?

A: While there are no missing-photo blunders on the scale of other sets of the time, 1991 Score is notorious for minor back-of-card text errors that were caught and corrected early in production.

Kent Anderson (card #224): The early error version has a typo in the first line of the second paragraph where “flashy” is misspelled as “flachy”. It was later corrected.

Mo Vaughn (card #750): Early copies accidentally credited Mo Vaughn with 44 Stolen Bases (SB) in a minor league stat row before Score corrected it to accurately reflect his home runs/RBIs.

Frank Thomas (card #840): The early “Franchise” subset card text misspelled his spring training location as “Sarasota” instead of Saratoga (or vice-versa depending on the plate batch) before a corrected version was issued.


Popular Rookie Cards From 1991 Score

1991 Score Mike Mussina 1st Round Draft Pick card #383
1991 Score Chipper Jones 1st Round Draft Pick rookie card #671
1991 Score Paul Abbott Rookie Prospect card #363
1991 Score Mike Lieberthal 1st Round Draft Pick card #683
1991 Score Mike Bordick Rookie Prospect card #339
1991 Score Todd Van Poppel 1st Round Draft Pick card #389