1991 Upper Deck Baseball

1991 Upper Deck baseball rookie card prices

Manufacturer: Upper Deck
Set Size: 800 Cards
Card Size: 2-1/2” x 3-1/2”

Set Notes: In 1991 Upper Deck baseball was released in two series. The first 700 are the low series. Numbers 701-800 make up the high series. Like most baseball card sets of the time, 1991 Upper Deck had a massive print run. Unopened boxes and packs are still available today at relatively low prices. Staying with their high design standards, the 1991 Upper Deck cards feature the silver foil hologram on back with player stats and photo. The Fronts feature a high quality player photo with green and tan line designs, Upper Deck logo and player name at bottom. 1991 was a good year for rookies as many well known names got their start this year.

Key Rookies From 1991 Upper Deck:   |  55Chipper Jones  |  65Mike Mussina  |  755Jeff Bagwell

Pricing chart includes raw card price & some graded card value estimates.
These values are collated from a variety of resources including recently sold listings, sales averages and a variety of other sports card pricing data sources. Please see full disclaimer on “Terms Page” for more information.
(Rookiecardprices.com only shows values for regular base set cards. No prices are shown for errors, parallels, subsets, misprints or other cards unless noted.)

DISCLAIMER: This data is not intended as financial advice and should not be used as such. Please do your own research before making any investment or selling/buying decisions.



() : No Pricing Data Available  |  ($) USD Price Value  |  (¢) USD Price Under $1

1991 Upper Deck Rookie Card Prices

RookieCard #Raw8910
Phil Plantier275¢ - - -
Lance Dickson975¢ - - -
Sean Berry1025¢ - - -
Brian Barnes1225¢ - - -
Narciso Elvira1350¢ - - -
Mike Gardiner1425¢ - - -
Greg Colbrunn1525¢ - - -
Henry Rodriguez2125¢ - - -
Eric Karros24$1 $5 - $15
Steve Decker2525¢ - - -
Kevin Belcher2625¢ - - -
Jeff Conine2775¢ - $3 $10
Terry Lee3725¢ - - -
Todd Van Poppel5375¢$10 $16 -
Steve Karsay5425¢ - - -
Chipper Jones55$1 $6 $15 $60
Chris Johnson5625¢ - - -
Gary Scott5825¢ - - -
Wil Cordero6025¢ - - -
Tim Costo6225¢ - - -
Brook Fordyce6425¢ - - -
Mike Mussina65$1 $5 $10 $30
Dave Staton6625¢ - - -
Mike Lieberthal6750¢ - - -
Kurt Miller6825¢ - - -
Dan Peltier6925¢ - - -
Reggie Sanders7175¢ - $5 $15
Len Brutcher7525¢ - - -
Pat Kelly7650¢ - - -
Orlando Merced8450¢ - - -
Anthony Telford30425¢ - - -
Craig Wilson39025¢ - - -
Pedro Munoz43225¢ - - -
Omar Olivares46325¢ - - -
Paul Abbott48750¢ - - -
Brian McRae54325¢ - - -
Mark Leonard55725¢ - - -
Luis Gonzalez567$1 - $8 $17
Scott Lewis59425¢ - - -
Jim Vatcher60425¢ - - -
Jeff Schulz60725¢ - - -
Tom Edens61625¢ - - -
Wes Chamberlain62625¢ - - -
Jim Neidlinger63225¢ - - -
Rich Rodriguez64025¢ - - -
Mike Bell64425¢ - - -
Joe Grahe65725¢ - - -
Mike Simms66425¢ - - -
Rafael Novoa67425¢ - - -
Jeff Gray68525¢ - - -
Rich DeLucia72725¢ - - -
Mike Perez72825¢ - - -
Rich Garces74125¢ - - -
Luis Mercedes74525¢ - - -
Paul Faries75125¢ - - -
Al Osuna75225¢ - - -
Steve Chitren75325¢ - - -
Jeff Bagwell755$1 $4 $18 $30
Kirk Dressendorfer75650¢ - - -
Denis Boucher76125¢ - - -
Turner Ward76225¢ - - -
Pete Schourek76625¢ - - -
Heathcliff Slocumb76725¢ - - -
Dana Allison77125¢ - - -
Joe Slusarski77775¢ - - -
Mike Timlin78575¢ - $10 -
Joe Bitker79725¢ - - -
Data Updated: March 2026

Right Now on eBay Shop 1991 Upper Deck Baseball Cards
Loading...
Clicking a link to eBay may result in a referral commission being paid if a purchase is made.

Overview of 1991 Upper Deck Baseball Cards

High Quality: Upper Deck was renowned for its glossy card stock, sharp photography, and overall superior production quality compared to its competitors like at the time. This gave the cards a more professional and aesthetically pleasing look.

Holograms: Each card back featured a small, anti-counterfeit hologram, a signature of Upper Deck’s early releases.

Full-Color Backs: Unlike some competitors, Upper Deck cards featured full-color backs with detailed statistical data and sometimes additional player information.

Series: The main set comprised 800 cards, released in two series (low-numbers #1-700 and high-numbers #701-800). There was also a “Final Edition” set released later in the year, featuring late-season call-ups and traded players.

Subsets: The set included various subsets such as “Rookie Stars,” “Top Prospects,” and team checklists.

Value Notes: Due to the immense production numbers of 1991 Upper Deck cards, most individual cards from the set have very little monetary value today, especially in ungraded condition. Complete sets can be found for relatively low prices. However, cards in perfect, gem-mint (PSA 10) condition of the key rookies and stars, particularly Chipper Jones can still fetch decent prices among collectors.

(Rookiecardprices.com only shows values for regular base set cards. No prices are shown for errors, parallels, subsets, misprints or other cards unless noted.)


Key Rookie Cards From 1991 Upper Deck

1991 Upper Deck Mike Mussina #65
1991 Upper Deck Chipper Jones #55
1991 Upper Deck Jeff Bagwell #755
1991 Upper Deck Luis Gonzalez #567
1991 Upper Deck Eric Karros #24