1996 Donruss Andy Pettitte #74 Baseball Card Values

Manufacturer: Donruss
Set: 1996 Donruss Baseball ➡️
Player Name: Andy Pettitte
Position/Team: Pitcher for Yankees
Card #: 74
Card Size: 2-1/2” x 3-1/2”
Card Value Snapshot: Raw/Ungraded: $1 | Grade 9: $16
⬇️ See More Pricing Data Below

Drafted by the Yankees in 1990, Pettitte debuted in 1995 and quickly established himself as a cornerstone of the legendary “Core Four” alongside Derek Jeter, Mariano Rivera, and Jorge Posada. By 1996, he was a 21-game winner and the American League Cy Young runner-up, helping guide the Yankees to their first World Series title in 18 years. He would win four titles during his first stint in New York (1996, 1998, 1999, 2000) before a three-year stretch with his hometown Houston Astros, where he teamed up with Roger Clemens to help lead Houston to its first-ever World Series appearance in 2005.

Pettitte returned to the Bronx in 2007 to finish his career where it started. He added a fifth World Series ring in 2009—clinching the ALDS, ALCS, and World Series titles in the exact same postseason—before retiring for good in 2013.

While his regular-season accomplishments are formidable, his true legacy was cemented in October.

256 Career Wins: A three-time All-Star, Pettitte finished with a 256–153 record and a 3.85 ERA. Remarkably, he never had a single losing season in his 18-year Major League career.
The King of October: Pettitte stands as the winningest pitcher in postseason history with 19 playoff victories. He also holds the all-time Major League records for postseason games started (44) and innings pitched (276.2).
Yankees Royalty: He remains the franchise’s all-time leader in strikeouts (2,020) and is tied with Whitey Ford for the most games started (438) in a Yankees uniform. His number 46 was officially retired by the team in 2015.

Shop current listings for this card on ebay!
Clicking a link to eBay may result in a referral commission being paid if a purchase is made.

Pricing Data For This Rookie Card

Tracking the current market value for the 1996 Donruss Andy Pettitte Card #74. Below, find updated pricing data for ungraded (raw) copies, as well as verified PSA graded sales trends collected from secondary marketplaces.

Raw/Ungraded: $1
Grade 8: $10
Grade 9: $16
Grade 10: -

Data Updated: June 2026

➡️ See All 1996 Donruss Rookie Card Prices

Pricing data includes raw card price & some graded card value estimates.
These values are collated from a variety of resources including recently sold listings, sales averages and a variety of other sports card pricing data sources. Please see full disclaimer on “Terms Page” for more information. (Rookiecardprices.com only shows values for regular base set cards. No prices are shown for errors, parallels, subsets, misprints or other cards unless noted.)

DISCLAIMER: This data is not intended as financial advice and should not be used as such. Please do your own research before making any investment or selling/buying decisions.